| The Apartment | Casablanca | Singin' In The Rain | |||
| Cast Member | Films Eliminated | Cast Member | Films Eliminated | Cast Member | Films Eliminated |
| Jack Lemmon | Mister Roberts | Peter Lorre | Arsenic and Old Lace | Gene Kelly | On The Town |
| The Fortune Cookie | Claude Rains | Here Comes Mr. Jordan | Inherit The Wind | ||
| Some Like It Hot | S. Z. Sakall | Yankee Doodle Dandy | Kathleen Freeman | The Blues Brothers | |
| The Odd Couple | Humphrey Bogart | Dead Men Don't Wear Plaid | Jean Hagen | Adam's Rib | |
| The Great Race | The Maltese Falcon | Rita Moreno | West Side Story | ||
| Good Neighbor Sam | Key Largo | Debbie Reynolds | Charlotte's Web | ||
| Ray Walston | Johnny Dangerously | Millard Mitchell | Winchester '73 | ||
| The Sting | |||||
| Fred MacMurray | The Absent-Minded Professor | ||||
| Double Indemnity | |||||
| The Shaggy Dog | |||||